It
was 1968 when the company Cambridge Audio was formed by legendary
designer Stan Curtis. Responsible for such classics as the Cambridge
Audio CD2 & CD3 these designs were radically innovative
of their time. The CD3 used 4x Philips TDA1541A and 16x oversampling to
push quantization noise higher above the audio band and enable a
simpler analogue filter.The
auction is for the modification only and does not include the Cambridge
Audio Azur 640C CD player which must be purchased separately.
30
years on Cambridge Audio’s innovation has evolved to produce some
excellent products which include the Azur range. At the top of this
strong line up is the flagship 840C but here we turn our attention to
the ward winning budget 840C V2. The glowing testimonies
of this player have earned 5 star rating and best CD player under £500
from What Hi-Fi, the “Gold Award” from Hi-Fi choice to name a few.
So What’s Under the Bonnet?
At the heart of the 640’S analogue circuits we find 2 x Wolfson WM8740 24-bit/192kHz DACs in dual differential configuration. These
dual DACs have been arranged in a symmetrical formation and Cambridge
claims this helps improve sound staging and stereo imaging. Features
also include a low resonance, acoustically damped chassis, high-specification toroidal transformer and a claimed low jitter clock. Budget kit has probably never looked better and with and all for an absurd giveaway of £250.00.
Under Scrutiny
The
640C sets new standards in its price class but at £250.00 one would
expect the 640C to have short comings and realistically it does. These
shortcomings are highlighted in a TNT audio review where the reviewer
explains these shortcomings; “Treble
isn't completely clean. Loud piano tones in busy parts do sound a bit
hard and the sound can become a little bit brittle at times. Bass lacks
some control and a fraction of bass detail is lost because of his.
Bowed double bass sound a little rough with less feeling of an actual
physical instrument than I know to be possible” ...”The whole mid and
treble actually sound a little bit 'bleached”...”the tendency of this
player to make things sound 'fast' makes slower fragments sound a
little bit hurried and unnatural.”
As
will all reviews the perception of sound quality is subjective but the
TNT review does paint an honest picture of the 640’s limitations and
concludes with a positive remark... “One
thing is absolutely certain: for the money this is one hell of a
player, and if you want something better you will have to pay much,
much more.” The
auction is for the modification only and does not include the Cambridge
Audio Azur 640C CD player which must be purchased separately.
More Marvellous Magic
Like
other Cambridge Audio products gone before it, the 640C’s excellent
circuit topology means serious improvements can be unlocked. With a
justifiable and practical expenditure the 640C V2 loses its foibles and
becomes a thoroughly capable and refined CD player.
The
640C is divided in to two main PCB’s, the servo PCB (digital) and main
PCB (digital & analogue), it is the main PCB which is the focus of
the Level-1 upgrades. Containing main power supplies, regulation,
master clock, DAC & analogue output stage this PCB is certainly
where most of the action happens.
First off we replace the ‘cooking grade’ capacitors used for power supply reservoir (smoothing AC) for Panasonic FC type. The
FC series although not selected as “audio grade” outperform several
types of electrolytic pitched at the audio market. The main PCB
contains several fixed voltage regulators for the +/- 15V analogue
supply, +5V DAC supplies. High grade bypassing is essential to reduce
noise and impedance on the power supply lines; here more general
purpose capacitors are upgraded to Rubycon ZA type, excellent for their
ultra-low impedance, E.S.R, and sound quality.
The
master clock in the 640C hides underneath a screening can and is
labelled ‘low jitter’. Beneath the can we find a TCXO which is powered
by a 7805 regulator. The output of the TCXO is buffered by a 14-pin
CMOS inverter and the outputs from this sent directly to the Wolfson WM8740 DAC’s.
This
arrangement has several drawbacks, the limited power supply rejection
of the 7805, output noise of the 7805, CMOS gate oscillator in the TCXO
has poor signal to noise ratio; the
selected crystals inside the TCXO have low Q and a used in parallel
mode, a method which is highly susceptible to digital noise injection.
To
attain the highest level of sound quality from these circuits the OEM
clock is removed and replaced with the Superclock 4 Ultra-low jitter
master clock. The virtues of Superclock 4 can be found here; http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=300150205626
The
post DAC filter in the 640C is a little unusual, it uses what is called
a ‘double balanced’ filter rather than the normal low-pass filter. A
total of 6x
NE5532 operational amplifiers follow the Wolfson WM8740 for filtering
and buffering. The 5532 is an ordinary consumer grade op-amp, a great
workhorse in its day but it can be significantly better by modern
op-amps. Here we use a mix a top spec op-amps costing 20x the price of
the 5532 to wring the most out of the WM8740 DAC’s. This is more than
icing on the cake, sonically it proves a revelation.
The
signal output of the 640C is capacitor coupled to ‘block’ DC, a pair of
capacitors lie in the signal path of each channel, a 100µF general
purpose non-polar electrolytic bypassed with a 2N2 film capacitor. This
combo of capacitors dirties and degrades the audio signal, a real
offender to the now excellent analogue stage. These capacitors are
removed and replaced with a single, Black Gate N series capacitor for
each channel. The N series are the highest grade Black Gate capacitors and
keep the total amount of distortion down to -150dB or less. Comparable
with high-performance film capacitors, these new capacitors provide
exceptional transparency, clarity and signal purity.
The
finishing touches are made with a sheet of Sontech SFRT-AL resonance
control panel for the lid to remove unwanted vibrations from entering
the sensitive electronics. The SFRT-AL is designed to remove specific
bands of vibration/noise turning into heat.
Showdown
The
640C V2 already ranks as the best player under £500.00 so what does
spending an extra £250.00 bring in real terms? We left the Level-1
modded 640C on repeat 24/7 for 100 hours before making our assessment.
To hand we had a couple of unmodified CD players, the Marantz SA-7001KI and Cambridge Audio's own 840C.
Having
another unmodified 640C to hand we sat down and made the comparisons.
Listening in to the unmodified 640C we started out with a man who knows
how to play piano; Ludovico Einaudi and his recent album Divenire was
set to play. On the title track ‘Divenire’, this excellent piece can be
beguiling and the stock 640C managed the intro well but as soon as the
track became more complex the highest treble notes started to harden
and the recordings leaner balance did not bode well with the 640C.
Moving to the modified 640C the same track ‘Divenire’ showed an
enormous shift in music making ability, the modified 640C was streets
ahead. The
piano sounded that much more real and 'live', the timbre and tones of
instruments were more believable. The music flowed effortlessly with
superb coherence keeping control and poise during the intricate shifts
in tempo.
Sting’s
Sacred Love album puts any CD player through its dynamic paces and the
unmodified 640C fared much better with this album. The sound was lively
and intelligible throughout and ‘Forget About The Future’ conveyed and
excellent sense of feeling. However, the powerful notes on this track
were understated, thinner, blander the sound compressed with less
space.
Switching
to the modded 640C and with the first track ‘Inside’ Sting had yet to
sing and the realisation of extra power, depth and spatial qualities
felt. Stings voice was strikingly real, full of meaningfulness; raspy
and rich in character. Behind the voice the instruments surged with
energy, control; details and nuances uncovered; the sound shimmering
with passion and life.
The
modded 640C’s finest achievement is that it maintains an open and
uncluttered perspective on all recordings, even those CD’s in the
‘don’t play’ box get a look in!
Summary
The
Level-1 modification delivers an outstanding upgrade to an already fine
player wringing out performance trapped in the OEM player’s circuits.
The improvements made to the stock 640C were shockingly good, its
ability to remain intelligible even when pushed, energetic when other
players are listless; all this and no right to sound as musical and
natural at the price means it easily rivals players costing £1K.
If
you are an existing owner of the 640C and have the itch to upgrade,
spending £250.00 on this upgrade will give you the biggest bang for
your buck, consider it unreservedly a bargain.
How to Order
The Cambridge Audio Azur 640C V1 or V2 Level-1 modification is supplied & installed by Audiocom for £250.00 inclusive (excludes carriage).
Once you have purchased the Level-1
modification please contact us to schedule and book your 640C for the
installation. We can offer reasonable rates for insured courier
collection & return to mainland UK from your home or workplace
(excludes weekends).
The modification work is completed with 4-5 working days from receipt of the CD player. The Level-1
modification is covered by a 2 year parts & labour guarantee, this
guarantee excludes any OEM parts such as laser & LCD display.